Comparing MPG figures directly will mislead you, so don’t. Compare the gallons each car uses over the same distance, then turn that into money.
Here are two popular 2025 models, using EPA combined figures and 12,000 miles a year at $4.17 a gallon.
| Ford F-150 2WD | Toyota RAV4 | |
|---|---|---|
| EPA combined | 20 MPG | 30 MPG |
| Gallons a year | 600 | 400 |
| Fuel a year | $2,502 | $1,668 |
That’s $834 a year between them, or $4,170 over five years, on fuel alone.
The trap in MPG
Which of these saves more fuel?
- Replacing a 15 MPG truck with a 20 MPG truck
- Replacing a 30 MPG sedan with a 40 MPG hybrid
The second looks better, since it gains 10 MPG rather than 5. It’s the other way around. Over 10,000 miles, the truck upgrade saves 167 gallons and the sedan upgrade saves 83. Researchers call this the “MPG illusion”, and it’s the reason European and Canadian figures are stated as fuel per distance instead.
If you own two cars and can only replace one, this usually points to replacing the thirstier one, even if the other seems to be the “old” car.
Use your own miles
The saving scales directly with how much you drive. At 6,000 miles a year, the F-150 and RAV4 gap falls to $417. At 20,000 it’s $1,390. A rarely driven car has little fuel to save, so a low-mileage owner should be slower to pay extra for efficiency.
Same fuel price, same conditions
Use one gas price for both cars, unless one needs premium, which can cost noticeably more per gallon. If it does, price them separately.
Try to compare figures from the same source too. EPA ratings for both are fair. Your measured 25 MPG against a sticker of 35 isn’t, since your own car has met the real world and the other hasn’t.
Look at gallons per 100 miles
EPA window stickers show gallons per 100 miles as well as MPG, and it’s the more honest number. The F-150 above uses 5 gallons per 100 miles and the RAV4 uses 3.3. That tells you directly that the truck burns 50% more fuel. Compare the same cars with MPG, and you’d have to do the sums yourself to see it.
Match the rating to your driving
Combined figures assume a particular mix of city and highway miles, and you may not drive that way. If you’re mostly in town, compare the city figures. The Honda Civic (31 city, 39 highway) and the Jeep Wrangler (20 city, 23 highway) are 11 MPG apart in town and 16 apart on the highway, so a highway commuter sees a bigger gap in that pair.
Hybrids turn this around. In a city, a hybrid’s advantage grows, because that’s where it can recover braking energy. A car-shopping comparison based on combined figures will undersell a hybrid to a city driver.
What fuel doesn’t tell you
Fuel is one line in the budget. A truck may hold its resale value better, and an SUV may cost less to insure. Use the vehicle comparison for the fuel side, and enter any price difference to see how long payback takes. Then weigh that against everything else that matters to you.
Vehicle ComparisonUse your own numbers