A worked example
Take a compact SUV at 26 MPG and a hybrid at 38 MPG, both driven 12,000 miles a year, with gas at $4.17.
- The SUV uses 462 gallons a year, which costs $1,925.
- The hybrid uses 316 gallons, which costs $1,317.
- The difference is about $608 a year.
If the hybrid costs $1,500 more to buy, it pays that back in about two and a half years. If gas dropped to $3.00, the saving falls to $437 a year and the payback stretches to about three and a half.
Why MPG can mislead you
MPG makes small improvements look small, and at the low end they’re not. Over 10,000 miles:
| Upgrade | Gallons saved | Saved at $4.17 |
|---|---|---|
| 15 to 20 MPG | 167 | $695 |
| 20 to 25 MPG | 100 | $417 |
| 30 to 40 MPG | 83 | $348 |
| 40 to 50 MPG | 50 | $209 |
Moving from 15 to 20 MPG saves twice what moving from 30 to 40 does, despite being half the size on paper. If a household has two cars, replacing the thirstier one almost always does more than replacing the efficient one.
Getting a fair comparison
Use figures from the same source for both cars. EPA ratings against EPA ratings work well. Your own measured MPG against a brochure figure doesn’t, because yours has dealt with real traffic and the brochure hasn’t.
Think about how you drive, too. If most of your miles are in town, the gap between a gas car and a hybrid is likely to be wider than the combined figures suggest. If you’re mostly on the highway, it may be narrower. Use the pick lists for a quick start, then change the numbers to match the trims you’re looking at.
And try a pessimistic gas price as well as an optimistic one. If a more efficient car only pays off when gas stays high, you’d be betting on prices. If it pays off at $3.00 too, it’s a much safer choice.
What this doesn’t decide for you
Fuel is one line in the cost of owning a car. A cheaper-to-fuel car with higher insurance or a faster-falling resale value can still cost you more. Use the tool to answer the fuel question, then look at the rest.
Questions people ask
Is the car with better MPG always cheaper overall?
No. It wins on fuel, but insurance, repairs, depreciation and the purchase price can change the result. Treat the payback figure as one input.
What should I use for distance per year?
Check your service records or last year’s odometer readings. If you have neither, 12,000 miles is a common assumption for a US driver.
How do I compare a gas car with a diesel?
This tool uses one fuel price, so it suits two cars on the same fuel best. For gas against diesel, price each car separately in the Fuel Cost Calculator.
Can I compare an electric car here?
Not fairly, because electricity is priced per kWh and this tool works with one liquid fuel price.