How to measure it
- Fill up until the pump clicks off. Don’t top it off.
- Reset your trip meter, or write down the odometer.
- Drive as you normally would, until you need gas.
- Fill up again, ideally at the same pump, and stop at the first click.
- Enter the distance on the trip meter and the fuel on the receipt.
That gives you one tank. Repeat it a few times, click “Add another tank”, and you will have a number that’s worth trusting.
Why you shouldn’t average your MPG readings
This one catches out almost everybody. Suppose you record three tanks:
| Tank | Miles | Gallons | MPG |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1, mixed | 312 | 11.4 | 27.4 |
| 2, city | 148 | 6.1 | 24.3 |
| 3, highway | 405 | 13.2 | 30.7 |
| All three | 865 | 30.7 | 28.2 |
Average the three MPG figures and you get 27.4. That treats the little city tank as equal to the long highway one. Divide the total miles by the total gallons and you get 28.2, which is the true answer. The calculator does this for you.
Sticker, dashboard and pump
You now have three numbers for one car, and they will rarely agree.
The EPA rating comes from standardized lab tests, which makes it good for comparing cars but less good at predicting your own. The dashboard is a running estimate. The pump method has small errors of its own, since no two fill-ups stop in quite the same place, but they even out across several tanks. For budgeting, trust the pump.
Questions people ask
Do I need to run the tank nearly empty?
No. You just need to start and finish at the same level, which in practice means full. Longer stretches are a little more accurate, because small differences in how you fill up count for less.
Can I use a partial fill-up?
Not by itself, since you do not know how much of the tank was left. Keep the receipt anyway. At your next full fill-up, add all the fuel you bought since the last full tank and divide the total distance by that.
Why doesn’t this match my dashboard?
The dashboard estimates fuel use from sensors. The pump measures what really went in, so a few percent of difference is normal, and many cars read a little optimistic.
My MPG suddenly dropped. Is something wrong?
One bad tank usually means weather, traffic or a heavy load. If it stays low for several tanks with the same driving, check tire pressure first, then have the car looked at.